This is the movie I promised myself I would never see. The trailer itself made it crystal clear: this is the story of one dog who keeps coming back to life as different breeds with different owners. And in order for a dog to be reborn – you guessed it – he has to die. A lot. And it’s never, ever not sad. But the film makes no bones about death not being the worst fate for dogs – and THAT was the worst part. The part when he didn’t die, but lived a miserable life.
Anyway, as if a dog’s repeated death wasn’t enough to deter me, there was some controversy prior to the film’s release when a video of one of the actor dogs revealed it looking completely terrified during a stunt. Abuse was alleged, which led people to boycott the film. Not that it mattered; A Dog’s Purpose is not terribly good. It was never going to win the box office. It preys on your heartstrings. The director is so shamelessly over-sentimental that I felt like a dog on a leash being yanked along against my will.
If you’ve been paying attention here, you may have noticed that Sean and I are dog lovers, or that I am a dog lover and Sean never really stood a chance. I already had Herbie when I met Sean, and Sean had to win his approval in order to stick around. Then we got Gertie so that Herbie would always have a friend. And then we adopted Fudgie on the day we bought our house. And Bronx was given to me as a post-surgery recovery gift. So that’s 4 – the maximum amount of animals we can have on our property without legally declaring ourselves a farm. They keep my life full and happy. There’s no better way to feel like a million bucks: simply leave home and return 10 minutes later. Tails will wag, joyous barks will sound, big sloppy kisses will greet you at the door.
While watching the movie, Sean had an epiphany: what if the only god that exists is the god of dogs. And this world belongs to the dogs. And we’re just here to act as their humble servants. And OUR purpose is to create better and better domestic situations for them. If that’s the case, dogs are benevolent masters, friendly and forgiving. Me? Not so much. This is one movie that deserved to be put down, but since it wasn’t, I caution you to tell it it’s a bad boy, a very bad boy, now maybe hit it in the nose with a rolled up newspaper and tell it to go lie down in its bed. And go hug a real dog instead.
I like Sean’s dog god epiphany. And yeah, just the premise of this movie put it on my don’t watch list. I still get teary from Hatchi and it’s been years since I saw it.
LikeLike
I really needed to give my dog a hug after this movie. It’s absolutely shameless in the way it makes you feel! Am I right in thinking there’s talk about a sequel?!
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are correct. It was a failure here in North American but Chinese audiences loved it so they’ll make a sequel that’s more directed toward a Chinese audience. It may not even get a theatre release here.
LikeLike
We can call this dog porn. When I need to cry (which I don’t) I may watch.
LikeLike
No No and thrice no! Can’t cope with doggies dying in movies, any movies, bad or good.
BTW Sean, silly boy, the world belongs to cats, duh. 😉
LikeLike
Didn’t it turn out the behind-the-scenes footage was edited in such a way to imply there was abuse when none had occurred? I forget the specifics…
Anyway, I’ve never seen Marley & Me because I know the dog dies, so watching a dog die over and over again? No thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, it was.
LikeLike
My husband, knowing I’m a sucker for all things canine, pointed the book out to me in Chapters several years ago and like a fool I bought it. Naturally I was in tears a mere few pages in, and things just went downhill from there.
Then I bought and read the sequel, because apparently I didn’t learn my lesson (and waste enough Kleenex) the first time around.
Sorry, movie. You don’t get to fool me thrice.
That said, I’m still waiting with bated breath to see if The Art of Racing in the Rain ever finally makes it to the screen, because if there’s one dog movie I would be willing to sob over, that would be it.
LikeLike
I did read (and sob) my way through that one. Jeez, eh?
LikeLike
There’s a sequel to the book? I am equally, excited, disappointed, curious and apprehensive upon hearing that.but
I really liked the book, but I was probably in the need of a good cry.
Now, the Art of Racing in the Rain..? I’ve read and loaned out many many times. One of my favorites.
I worry a movie could corrupt it both books. As in the way Seabiscuit ruined movie watchers from trusting the great reviews of their book reader counterparts.- if that makes any sense..?)
Ever read Walking in Circles Before Laying Down? I think its one you’d like.
Modoc, is another great book, about an elephant I highly recommend (but is not a true story as it portrays itself to be.) And could be made into a promising movie, as in the way Life of Pi was.
LikeLike
Haha! This sounds incredibly awful. An achievement in awfulism, in fact.
LikeLike
The bad press surrounding this movie’s launch had kept me from seeing it. If I need a good cry though it sounds like one to watch.
LikeLike
I’m a dog lover and movie lover, but don’t feel the need to cross-polinate the two in this regard. Thanks for saving me from it. =)
LikeLike
I love dogs as it’s been nearly 2 years since my dog passed and a nearly a year since my cat passed as well. I refuse to see this.
LikeLike
Nopenopenopenope.
LikeLike
Dogs dying in movies makes me cry all the time! It actually happens with books too! Don’t get me started on Lily and the Octopus! But I actually have this book sitting on my shelf and I may read it in small doses! When, you know, I really need to cry!
LikeLike
I am a HUGE dog lover, Jay. The trailer had me in tears. But I did have the feeling I would be beaten into submission and forced to have some sort of cathartic emotional experience akin to early Spielberg films. No, I don’t like films that tell me what response I should have. Good review and I think I will pass.
LikeLike
I wondered about this movie…. thanks Jay, I WIL avoid at all cost
LikeLike
My kids wanted to see this and I avoided it. Now that it is out at home, they’ve asked again. So, I’ve read this review to them. We no longer have to see this movie.
LikeLike
Great review – so funny. I have no plans to see this movie. I like Sean’s epiphany about who really rules the world. If only it were so. *Sigh* The world would be in much better shape. 🙂
LikeLike
I avoided it because I hate sobbing in movie theatres, but you’ve given me another reason to make sure Ken never rents it either!
LikeLike
I’ve been through having to say goodbye to too many real dogs to ever subject myself to a movie where a dog dies over and over. Instead I’ll stick with the idea of a god of dogs, because loving a dog and being loved in return is heavenly.
LikeLike
I’m more of a cat person but I saw the trailer for this and felt the tears coming from a mile away so I know I’ll never, ever see it. Or Marley & Me. Never.
LikeLike
I got the feeling that this movie was more about reincarnation than a repeatedly dying dog. Still, the trailer convinced me this was a no go.
LikeLike
Thank you! 100% steering clear.
LikeLike
I liked the way you have reviewed amazing
LikeLike
I hated the book 😦
LikeLike