TIFF18: The Kindergarten Teacher

Lisa is having a mid-life crisis. No, Lisa (Maggie Gyllenhaal) is having an existential mother fucking emergency. She’s been a kindergarten teacher for 20 years and she’s tired of teaching a curriculum she doesn’t believe in. She feels invisible at home, a mother to grown kids who don’t need her anymore, a wife to a man she doesn’t feel connected to. A continuing education class in poetry only highlights her unrealized potential and stifled creativity.

So Lisa is ripe for a prodigy, and what do you know, she “discovers” one right in her own classroom. Five (and a half) year old and full-time cutie-patootie Jimmy (Parker Sevak) MV5BMTYxODY2NDU5MV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwNDE3MTgyNDM@._V1_composes poetry that is beautiful and eloquent beyond his years. Lisa feels an addictive high when she recites it as her own in poetry class, receiving praise by peers and teacher (Gael  Garcia Bernal) alike. But mostly she just becomes obsessed with this kid, believing she’s the only one who can nurture his talent. Her behaviour becomes increasingly troublesome, though even on the mild end of the spectrum (depriving him of naps, luring him into bathrooms, alone, with candy bribes), I was uncomfortable.

Lisa is a complex character. You’re picking up on that, right? She legitimately believes she’s got a Mozart-level genius on her hands, and also that our current culture crushes creativity. And she’s not wrong, definitely not about one of those things, and maybe not about both. But she believes that gives her the right to overstep her bounds in some pretty major, pretty outrageous ways.

Maggie Gylleenhaal deserves every good word you have to say about her performance. It’s melancholy, human, and desperate. There’s something universal about a woman’s unsatisfied needs. But you don’t quite know where or how far Lisa will take this – it’s just slightly unhinged, which keeps you riveted despite the fact that the film sometimes feels like it’s not quite sure what it should be.

Director Sara Colangelo explores the many facets of her protagonist even when motivations are muddled and compromised. There’s almost a dark comedy running through the veins of this movie, throbbing and daring in a way that’s surprising given it takes place in a kindergarten class. You’ll laugh, you’ll wince, you’ll sympathize, you’ll condemn, but you won’t look away, even when it stumbles, even if it can’t commit. The Kindergarten Teacher offers a confident performance and a fascinating character study.



Catch The Kindergarten Teacher on Netflix October 12.

14 thoughts on “TIFF18: The Kindergarten Teacher

  1. dbmoviesblog

    Stellar review. I am looking forward to seeing this and I particularly like that you also refer to this film as a “dark comedy”. I also think that Gyllenhaal deserves more recognition for her work now. Having said that, I think some credit is also due to the original Israeli movie The Kindergarten Teacher (2014).

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Bryan Fagan

    I like it when the writers push the audience to the edge. A teacher luring a five year old to the bathroom is a test to see how we’ll react. From your review there’s nothing sexual about it. She simply wants to nurture this boy’s talent. Sadly, our culture puts a stop to such things.

    Movies like this, if done well, can send a strong message. I hope this one does.

    Another one I need to check out. Thanks!!!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Christopher

    This sounds as though it could have been inspired by–albeit very different from–the relationship between Arthur Rimbaud and Georges Izambard. Rimbaud was fifteen and already an accomplished poet and Izambard was twenty-two. It just seems like most stories that deal with this sort of relationship focus on the prodigy and it’s interesting that this one gives more attention to the mentor.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. filmsCine

    Seems like the lead character has a few more layers than the Kindergarten Cop, then.

    Fab review! I saw the trailer for this and was very very interested. It did seem in the trailer like she could be pushing the boundaries towards the ol’ paedophilic tendencies.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Pingback: ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIESTIFF18: Female Voices

  6. Pingback: ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIESTop 10 Female-Directed Movies 2018

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s