Two young people are trying to have sex, apparently on their wedding night, which is important to note because they’re old-timey virgins who are nervous and awkward and don’t really know where things go or for how long or how hard.
Somewhere between toes and tits, Florence (Saoirse Ronan) and Edward (Billy Howle) reminisce about their entire relationship, through flashbacks. Spoiler alert: they have a history! Their courtship was often influenced (often negatively) by their pasts, by their families, by what they know and what they don’t. Sound familiar? That’s probably because it’s true of absolutely every human who has ever lived. So how did this movie get made?
Well, Ian McEwan wrote a wonderfully descriptive book, as he does. The kind of book that languishes and meanders around in a poetic bath of language. On film, oh gosh, it’s beautiful, and Saoirse Ronan is luminous and wonderful, but there’s not a whole lot of action. Haha, even saying the word action in this context feels bizarre. I mean, on their hottest date, Edward chastises Flo for her lukewarm bird watching.
Anyway, if you find it hard to imagine what sex was even like in 1962, before the sexual revolution had really…revolved…well, consider yourself lucky. On Chesil Beach gives you an eyeful in all its pasty glory, which doesn’t actually involve any nudity because this is the generation that has never seen their partners naked. Anyway, the fumbling is real. Activities are prematurely aborted, or, well, not quite. Things are said. Things like: that’s revolting, which is hard to recover from. It begs the question: does sex just sometimes…not happen? ‘Frigid’ is another word you don’t recover from.
Anyway, the whole thing feels rather minor, and that’s not a comment on poor Eddie’s manhood. It’s just very introspective, and perhaps a visual medium is not quite the best path for this story. And the movie just stretches on and on, beyond what feels right or makes sense. Certainly beyond my patience, and beyond the tether of my empathy for these people. The film fails its characters and fails the audience by not having much of a bigger picture. At least with a book you can hurl it across the room – hell, I’m sure I’ve even broken a window or two launching a stupid book right through it, but a movie? Those faces loom so large and yet I cannot reach out and slap them, and that is the greatest travesty of all.
Yeah, this film was WAY too subtle for its own good. Lots of good scenes but it did not hold together in my view. Despite the fine performances from a great cast – it probably should have been left on the page.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Interesting. Ronan is always fab! I would quite like to see this, mainly because our main man there Billy Howle was in the year above me at school. He always did excel at drama!
LikeLiked by 4 people
Thanks for the review. I’ve been on the fence about seeing it. Read the book and loved it. Curious about the movie though. Might give it a go.
LikeLike
Hi Jay🌷😊
Do people see their parents nude?😳
Too bad the film didn’t jell well for the audiences. It certainly had the right material and cast. I enjoy the details you give in your reviews. It makes it clear where the flaws are in the movie making.👍🏼
LikeLike
Yes, and sometimes the flaws are just with the viewer, which means that others may enjoy a movie I don’t, and I hope to point that out too, when I can!
LikeLiked by 1 person
also:
never seen their partners naked
PARTNERS, I said partners!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oops! Sorry about that😊
LikeLike
could be a hit
with the family
values audience 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for visit and LIKE ! 🙂
Alioșa ! 🙂
LikeLike
To be honest, the book was very slight. McEwen never seems to film well. You’re right, perhaps it is because the books are so ‘interior ‘.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes it was, it’s a weird choice to adapt but I suppose they’ve just gotten in the habit and someone buys the rights just on autopilot.
LikeLike
Yawn.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello there. This movie sucks big-time, to put it generously. All kinds of anguishing about things that the parties involved should have been able to figure out and deal with intelligently.
I saw Blaze yesterday. It’s good, but a lot of the dialogue is hard to make out, which is unfortunate.
Take care —
Neil S.
LikeLike
I have just finished this and found it pretty depressing. Even their courtship seemed rather drab. Is the book any better?
LikeLike