SXSW: Making The Grade

My grandmother had a very old, very creaky stand up piano in her dining room. Once we’d eaten all her cookies and drawn all over her church stationery, we’d pound away on the untuned keys, convinced we were making loud, beautiful music. We were not. But lessons were for rich people and we were not that either.

This documentary acquaints us with a whole spectrum of Irish piano students, those studying for their first grade exams all the way to the 8th. Old and young are peppered randomly throughout; some have natural ability and others are a little plonkier, but they’re all more dedicated than me. The kids astound me, of course. The piano seems the antithesis of our sped-up society and I’m impressed that any of them have the chutzpah to put in adequate practice, persevere through the tough spots, and pursue an accomplishment that isn’t very well rewarded anymore. But my favourite of director Ken Wardrop’s subjects is a woman with short gray hair and colourful tunics who persists though she’s the first to admit she isn’t any good. I suppose that’s what I admire most: yes, the music sounds better coming from the fingers of someone for whom this comes easily – but it’s so much sweeter coming from the clumsy fingers of a woman who possesses not the teeniest drop of rhythm.

Making the Grade isn’t flashy. There are no stylish tricks. But you’ll find that simply pointing the camera at a bunch of people who know a secret – well, the camera loves secrets, doesn’t it? This is what documentaries are for: exposing those we wouldn’t otherwise know. Whether it’s a little girl discover power and confidence in her music, or a woman finding solace and self-care in hers, it’s moving just to see others be moved by music of their own creation. And of their teachers? This is a loving tribute.

7 thoughts on “SXSW: Making The Grade

  1. Carrie Rubin

    This sounds interesting. I was one of those weird kids who actually liked practicing piano. Of course, this was in the dark ages, so that might have had something to do with it.


    1. Jay Post author

      I wish I had grown up playing something but if I’m being honest, I’m not sure I would have stuck with it. And I am certainly a giver upper as an adult: I bought a very expensive guitar, took 2 lessons, and then sold it at a huge loss.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. calensariel

    I had the same experience with my uncle’s piano (which we couldn’t touch if he was there – my aunt didn’t care). When my mom passed away I took part of the money she left me and bought a 1927 upright grand for $500 from our church, had it repaired, restained, and refinished. It’s gorgeous. THEN Stef and I took piano lessons. Trouble was, for me it was about 45 years too late. I was 50! Once you’ve become a perfectionist, forget it! If I made a mistake, I insisted on starting again. My piano teacher was very gentle when she delivered my prognosis! LOL She said to keep playing at home just for myself. Unfortunately it didn’t turn out to be the outlet I’d always hoped for. 🙂


    1. Jay Post author

      Oh but she is beautiful.

      Yes, I tried to learn the guitar as an adult and found it difficult – it’s hard to be humble and start as a beginner, really. And do I really have the patience??



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s