Mary Poppins Returns

Mary Poppins Returns is practically perfect in every way. It looks wonderful, whimsical, fanciful, a dreamscape. The animated sequences are next-level. The choreography is lively and polished. The costuming, by genius Sandy Powell, makes me tremble, its candy colours and hand-painted detailing an absolute riot. It’s wearable happiness.

And the cast. The cast! Ben Whishaw and Emily Mortimer play Michael and Jane Banks, the original kids from the first Mary Poppins, all grown up. Julie Walters tinkers in the kitchen as the hard-working maid, Ellen. Lin-Manuel Miranda plays Jack, the effervescent but largely ineffective lamp lighter (he might light 3 lamps total during the course of a 2 hour movie because his song and dance breaks are so frequent; the lamp lighter’s union must be fabulous). Together, they’re already a dream cast, but then MV5BY2I4NTRiM2UtYzIxYS00MTkyLTk4Y2ItYmNjNWNlMzZiYzdjXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyNTc5OTMwOTQ@._V1_director Rob Marshall plunks down Emily Blunt as the iconic nanny, Mary Poppins. Ho-lee shit. I mean, every ounce of credit to Julie Andrews, but since she’s vacated the seat, Emily Blunt is absolutely the perfect choice to carry the carpet bag. Anyone else in the role is simply unimaginable. And Colin Firth and Meryl Streep are BONUSES? Ex-squeeze me? Pure casting heaven.

But here’s the deal: despite there not being a single smudge dirtying up the glass, the magic just wasn’t there for me. I wanted to love this movie. Maybe I wanted it too much. It has all the right ingredients, but the pinch of disappointment is all I can taste.

Michael Banks is in a spot of trouble. His wife died a year ago, leaving him in charge of the house and the kids. All are neglected. His adorable children aren’t just raising themselves, they’re taking care of him too. Just about the only thing they can’t do is save the house from foreclosure. Michael and Jane can’t do it either – neither has any money. Where or where are those stock certificates their father left them? They’ve only got a few days to save their family home from the evil banker, Colin Firth. Cue Mary Poppins. Nominally, she’s taking care of the children, but I think her main ambition is just to allow them to be children again. And ideally, force Michael to act like the father again. So that’s the plot, and then we continually interrupt the plot to do some wild Mary Poppins shenanigans. The dancy, singy, cartoony musical numbers are incredible, or they would be if the songs weren’t so negligible, but they grind the plot to a halt and don’t relate to the rest of the movie at all. It’s not cohesive; I feel like I was watching two different movies, part depression-era family tragedy, part nostalgic stuff and nonsense. There are some wonderful call-backs to the original film, but I feel like Mary Poppins returns relies too heavily on its predecessor and our forgiveness. I wanted so badly to be carried away by this, but I remained firmly in my seat, butt against leather, popcorn in the cracks (of the recliner, not my ass). Translation: perfectly ordinary in every way.

30 thoughts on “Mary Poppins Returns

  1. curious•pondering

    Sadly, I have heard only bad things about this movie. I really want to like it and am still excited to see it, but I am taking it with a grain of salt.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Jay Post author

      Yeah, I realized that too, walking out. I couldn’t really point to anything wrong, just that there was an absence of wow.
      And if you’re going to touch a class, you better bring the wow. Justify yourself!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Sunshiny SA, Kavitha

        The battle scenes were a little prolonged. Not the best as previous BUT my son is not going to be this age always, so pleased him. I would rather have gone to see Bohemian Rhapsody but i wont tell my son that.


  2. joel watches movies

    noooooooooo this review took the most unpleasant and unexpected turn after it began with “Mary Poppins Returns is practically perfect in every way.” No fault of yours, of course, Jay, I just really wanted to love this too and am sad that it looks like I probably won’t as much as I hoped. Ah well, good to temper my expectations before seeing it so I won’t be as disappointed while watching, I suppose.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Benjamin Fastnedge

    I think Mary Poppins returns is cohesive. There is a clear story arc running through it and I don’t think the musical numbers interrupted the plot. I think with any musical you have to allow a slight surge into a different direction, before recomposure and picking up the plotline again. I really enjoyed it!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. In My Cluttered Attic

    Hey Jay, I’m so sorry you didn’t enjoy this one as much as our family. Being one who loves the original I thought everyone here did a fabulous job of living up to expectations. It’s not the original, but it’s damn close. Anyway, I didn’t think it was all that bad as a follow-up, and my wife (the ultimate film critic—hates this kind of fluff) adored it. Go figure! Can’t get the tunes outta my head. Only complaint…Julie didn’t sneak in there somewhere. Other than that, our family and their kids all enjoyed it. All the same, nice review. Oh, and Jay, HAPPY NEW YEARS! 😀


    1. Jay Post author

      Yes, Ms. Andrews said she felt she’d be too much of a distraction and she really wanted Emily to be able to fully own the role, and I do kind of get that.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Pingback: ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIESDisney’s Magic Kingdom

  6. Pingback: ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIESThe Lion King (1994)

  7. Pingback: ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIESOscar Spotlight: Costume Design


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s