Samantha’s grandmother was the keeper and maker of family traditions. This year will be Samantha’s first without her Nana, and it feels like it’s going to be a sad one, especially since she’s fighting writer’s block. But looks like Nana left one last surprise: an invitation arrives to spend one last Christmas at her house, with the whole family gathered near (including Sam’s mother, though her parents are divorced). So Sam and boyfriend Simon nix their Aspen plans for their first Christmas together and set out instead for her hometown.

Turns out, Nana’s about as demanding as Gerard Butler was in P.S. I Love You. In fact, a whole list of traditions to be fulfilled arrives, and the family has to really come together to make gingerbread cookies, ice skate, trim the tree, all those good things, many of which you probably do yourself. “Traditions are the stories that families write together,” Nana always said.

If you know the Hallmark formula, then you know that the protagonist always has a reason to hate Christmas, and on the journey to embracing the holiday season, they also fall in love. Reunited For Christmas falls a teeny tiny bit outside that comfortable, homogeneous Hallmark box in that Samantha starts out with a boyfriend, and he’s not horrible, or a workaholic, or a secret misogynist. And Samantha doesn’t hate Christmas, she’s just finding the holidays hard as she struggles with grief and loss. I think a lot of us can relate. That first holiday without a loved one feels marked by their absence, and it’s hard to really get in the holiday spirit. At any rate, Samantha is less in the way of her own self than almost any Hallmark heroine before her, and for that, I salute her. I still didn’t love the movie, but feel strongly the need to applaud any of Hallmark’s lineup that dares to stray even the teensiest bit from their very well-beaten path. I mean, what have we come to societally that what we need from Christmas is a bunch of carbon-copied, low on production value movies that are as predictable as they are overflowing with schmaltz? This year a deviation from formula, next year people of colour! LGBTQ+ story lines! A Jewish holiday special! Who knows?

Imagine having a job in December. Imagine needing to both work AND wrap presents. Impossible, right? I mean, truthfully, I think a lot of us manage it, but in Hallmark movies, they’re always the protagonist’s undoing. They simply cannot manage the epic balancing act of going to work and listening to loads of religious Christmas carols. It’s tough. It’s nearly insurmountable, which is why the protagonists must always learn some important and hopefully heartwarming lessons about priorities and the meaning of Christmas.

Laurel, a Chicago business woman, travels to Memphis around the holidays to secure the acquisition of a local bank for her Grinch of a boss. Laurel (Kellie Pickler) is in fact a Memphis native, so she’s got an inside edge when it comes to the bank owner, who actually cares about his employees. But she’s also got a lot of old connections to rekindle – a best friend from college, and an old flame-slash-music partner with whom she “almost had a record deal.”

Laurel is excited to show her daughter a real Memphis Christmas, and Graceland most of all, and she connects with the bank guy who practically folds her right into the family. And of course stuff between she and her ex, Clay (Wes Brown) heat up, predictably (why did they even break up?), so when Laurel’s boss calls her back to Chicago suddenly, oh boy, Christmas gets very, very sad.

Now, you can’t have an Elvis-themed Christmas movie with a country-western singer as its star and not have LOTS of musical numbers. While they do in fact film in actual Graceland, they clearly cannot afford actual Elvis songs, so don’t get attached to anything specific, but Laurel and Clay find every excuse in the book to duet. They even go Christmas caroling, and I think we need to talk about that for a moment.

The transaction of Christmas caroling has always felt very awkward to me. I mean, you stand on someone’s lawn, unbidden, and sing until you’re noticed. In 2018, it’s a rare person who will come to the door unless they’ve ordered a pizza. Well, a rare person under the age of 60 anyway. And if you do answer your door, you just stand there like an idiot, shivering, letting all the warmth of your house escape, sending your heating bill through the roof trying to heat the outdoors, so you can listen to a song you explicitly skipped church to avoid – and then what? Applause? Are you supposed to tip? How grateful do you have to be when someone interrupts your evening with something you never asked for? I mean, they’re like the holiday version of a mariachi band who serenades your table until you literally pay them to leave.

Anyway, there’s lots of Memphis twang to this Hallmark movie (there’s even a scene dedicated to the appreciation of a Hallmark card, almost as blatantly as when Netflix movies have people watching Netflix movies in them. Kellie Pickler isn’t really an actress but she’s still better than 60% of the wooden puppets usually cast in these things, and Wes Brown is sexy as hell. So if you’re happy to have a little gospel in your Christmas viewing, I guess you could do worse. I’ve done much worse, believe me.

This movie erroneously boasts that it’s in the style of Love Actually but whether you love or hate Love Actually, there’s no option but the big ole hate button for A Christmas In New York.

It’s about 6 couples who are all staying in the same New York hotel around Christmas. There’s an old couple, a young couple going to prom, an ex-couple excavating some relationship skeletons, a couple fighting about whether to start a family, a couple having an extramarital affair, and a musician who’s on tour and missing his kid – and, I guess, having sex with groupies. Or something.

Anyway, the editing is so atrocious that we coldly flip back and forth between the stories without ever getting invested in any one, let alone all. And it’s not that any of the stories are particularly good or original or interesting anyway.

And the thing is, I love Christmas in New York, you know, the actual holiday in the actual city. I love the lights and the window displays and going to Macy’s and seeing the Rockettes, and the big tree at Rockefeller Center. It’s magical. You know what’s not magical? Stock footage of New York, and a California shooting location. That’s a lot less magical.

This movie does not have a charmingly licentious Bill Nighy, or the unforgettable dance moves of Hugh Grant, or the romantic proposal lost in translation by Colin Firth, or the terrific, heartbreaking acting by Emma Thompson. It has nothing, really, except delusions of grandeur.

If you want a New York Christmas experience, may I suggest hitting yourself in the head with a cast iron skillet while streaming the Macy’s parade on Youtube. It’ll be 1000% more authentic.

Did you ever wonder what would have happened had Charles Dickens been raised in a trailer park? Me neither, actually, but this movie is determined to answer the question that nobody asked, and it turns out the answer is even more dismal than you may have (briefly, just then) imagined.

Cindy (Taryn Manning) is a trashy trailer park fixture. She’s allergic to work and has a collection of scruffy kids from different daddies, one of whom has just died in a paint balling accident as untragic as they come. His redneck funeral is an occasion for her to once again lean on her generous boyfriend while flirting with the bad boys who impregnate and leave her. Cindy hates Christmas, and it looks like the tree will once again be bare, as “the claw machine ain’t been kind to Mama.”

Second-rate Cindy gets a second-rate redemption. She is visited by 3 ghosts (you guessed it: past, future, present), and the sad thing is, even Scrooge got a better reception. Her ghosts are just as junky and bargain basement as she is, which is a damn shame. For once I found myself sympathizing with Cindy, in that these ghosts were doing a piss poor job of convincing me too. Will Cindy ever come around? Um, yes. What else is the point? This is a Christmas movie, albeit a difficult to identify one, and there are certain protocols to be followed. Happy endings are a must. And even a writer dumb enough to rewrite Dickens isn’t fool enough to think he can best him.

Taryn Manning is of course perfect for this role, as long as we all agree that this role needed to exist in the first place. She parades around in booty shorts that are mostly booty and hardly shorts. Her hair is never brushed, her kids are never tame, she hasn’t got a touch of class. Beverly D’Angelo plays her mother, and I assume that was a pretty low point in her career – probably didn’t make the D’Angelo family Christmas letter, despite its being seasonally appropriate. The movie is dumb. I wish it was at least dumb fun but it’s not, it’s just a frustrating, useless ball of goop, like gum on the sole of your shoe. Better to have not stepped in it in the first place.